A Baby Elephant is Born

Filed under: Uncategorized, Animal Rescue Alert!, 3 All About Gaia Wild, State[ment] of Mind — Diane at 1:33 pm on Friday, August 10, 2007

Asian elephant Maharani gave birth to a 140-kg (308 lb) female calf at the Calgary Zoo yesterday (Thursday, August 9). The little one has not yet been named.

This is Maharani’s second calf in three years. She gave birth in November of 2004 as well, but rejected the calf, and without the mother-child bond that is so necessary in high-level, highly social mammals, the calf failed to thrive, and soon died.
As a result, the zoo team sweated Maharani’s 22-month pregnancy this time around. The captive breeding program is part of a worldwide effort to save Asian elephants from extinction. Every birth is celebrated, and with every death, we fail a population that is disappearing to habitat encroachment and poaching.

The fear that Maharani may again fail to bond with her infant may be one reason the zoo is holding off naming the baby. Once we name something, we connect to it. And once we’re connected, any loss hurts all the more. But when you see a photo of this newborn elephant, bewildered by birth and struggling for life, you will feel connected, name or no name.

This elephant’s birth reminds me of another elephant born in captivity not so very long ago - April 26, 1970. Tina spent 34 years of her life in a small enclosure at the Greater Vancouver Zoo, much of it in a state of extreme boredom and loneliness and suffering serious foot problems because of the surfaces on which she stood. When it came to light that the Zoo was planning to sell her to a circus operator known to have abused his other animals, journalist Nicholas Read sparked a huge media campaign, bringing in Peter Fricker of the Vancouver Humane Society and Julie Woodyer of Zoocheck Canada, and leading to an enormous outcry from a public who had long held Tina in great affection. The result was a massive rescue effort that led to Tina’s journey to the Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee, where she spent the last year of her life in the company of her own kind, in as much freedom as she had ever seen in her lifetime.

It took me less than a second — the time it takes to see a photograph, to absorb its content and process what that content means to me — to fall in love with Maharani’s new baby. I can even applaud the Calgary’s Zoo’s contribution to conservation efforts; wild animals don’t belong in zoos, but in so many cases now, zoos may have become their only hope for survival as a species.

But I can’t forget Tina, or how much she suffered (despite how much she was loved). We have Zoocheck to tell us how well our zoos are doing on the animal welfare front. But we don’t have the laws in place to enforce Zoocheck’s standards, should a zoo fail to meet them.

It is not enough to bring them into the world. We need to make the world a safer place to bring them into. We need to do more. We need to change the laws.

Go look at her photo, little whatever-her-name-will-be. Fall in love. And then find out what you can about the laws designed to protect her. We are her guardians.

3 Comments »

592

Comment by Amy

August 12, 2007 @ 8:46 am

Using the word conservation in this context is a misnomer. No captive-born elephant has ever been returned to the wild.

Real conservation is the preservation of animals and their natural habitats in their native countries. If zoos put as much money into real conservation, and into finding solutions to the conflicts between people and wildlife, as they do into their own marketing budgets, you’d be surprised what could be accomplished. Yes — disappearing habitats is an enormous problem. But that doesn’t mean we should abandon them and instead support zoos that breed wild animals who will spend their lives in barren, too-small enclosures for our entertainment.

628

Comment by Jacquie

August 18, 2007 @ 9:24 pm

Interesting posts! And I see what you mean about falling in love when you see the baby elephant’s photos. Being cute does help.

643

Comment by Diane

August 20, 2007 @ 11:22 pm

Hi Amy,

Thanks for writing. I’m with you. The word “conservation” is, in this case, the one the Calgary Zoo uses to describe their program. As you point out, it’s the one most zoos use to justify their existence.

I find the question of the usefulness of zoos a challenging one, and it’s becoming more so as natural habitat for so many animals continues to disappear. The next book in my series will focus on the question of wildness — what it means to be wild, whether zoos have a role in wild animal welfare, etc. I am both looking forward to, and feeling anxious about, wrestling with some of these questions. What’s important to me with the book is creating a story that lets readers tackle the questions for themselves, without necessarily offering a clear answer.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>